Woody.pasa@XEROX.ARPA (07/30/84)
There's this accounting computer at the Santa Fe, (where my dad works),
and before it was installed, accounting was something which needed a very
intelligent person to do. It required a high level of intelligence to keep
the books balanced, the type of intelligence a machine could never have.
The Santa Fe uses a computer to keep all their books now.
But note that the discussion with accounting is now not "The computer is
intelligent--look, it can keep the accounting books for an entire company",
but "Gee, anyone can keep the accounting books; even a computer."
The Turing test is a poor test, granted; but can there be a more
generalized test to tell if a computer is truly intelligent? With the
Turing test, we can give the computer and the human at the other end a
test in math, understanding, and creativity; we could even talk about
the presidential elections; we're not restricted to the things that
have been discussed earlier.
As for hooking up a camera to the computer and using visual
identification as a test for intelligence: I know of a few blind
people who would be hard-pressed to past that test. Sure, it takes a
lot to be able to see, but then most mice can see, and some humans
cannot; does that make the mice smarter than the humans?
- Bill Woody
1-60 Caltech
Pasadena, CA 91126