[net.med] Vitamin A and "brain tumors"

dyer@wivax.UUCP (Stephen Dyer) (12/11/83)

The person who reported on vitamin A toxicity did NOT say that
overdoses of vitamin A cause brain tumors.  He said that it causes
symptoms which may mimic the symptoms of a brain tumor (hence causing
doctors treating the patient to waste time looking for something that
isn't there.)  25000 IUs of Vitamin A is the largest amount allowed in
over-the-counter vitamin pills, since this is already 5 times higher
than the Recommended Daily Allowance.  There is a margin of safety here
before chronic toxicity becomes a possibility (roughly a factor of 5 or
6 for an adult male), but that is completely dependent on the individual's
metabolism, age, and how long the vitamin has been given.  The FDA limits
it to 25000 IU for good reason, given the way some people treat vitamin pills.
Incidentally, overdoses of carotenoids (those pigments found in carrots
and other vegetables which the body converts to vitamin A) might turn your
skin yellow, but they don't seem to cause toxicity.

I quote from Goodman and Gilman's "The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics"
(a gem of a book, by the way, for those who feel comfortable with medical
technical writing) page 1587, Sixth Edition, 1980:

"Early signs and symptoms of @i(chronic) vitamin A intoxication include
irritability, vomiting, loss of appetite, headache, dry and pruritic
skin, skin desquamation, and erythematous dermatitis.  Fatigue, pain
in ankles and feet, myalgia, loss of body hair, papilledema, nystagmus,
gingivitis, mouth fissures, and lymph node enlargement have been observed.
In addition to hepatosplenomegaly, pathological changes in the liver
include hypertrophy of fat-storing cells, fibrosis, scelerosis of central
veins, and cirrhosis, with resultant portal hypertension and ascites.
--->>>>Intracranial pressure may be increased, and neurological symptoms
--->>>>may mimic that of a brain tumor.  The diagnosis is usually made
following the appearance of tender, deep, hard swellings on the extremeties
and occipital region of the head.  Hyperostoses in the underlying bone
area are easily demonstrated roentgenographically.  The activity of
alkaline phosphatase in plasma rises because of the increased osteoblastic
activity, and a number of cases of hypercalcemia have been reported."

(Swallow THAT as you swallow your vitamins!)
-- 
/Steve Dyer
decvax!bbncca!sdyer
sdyer@bbncca