[net.med] The great sugar debate

rickc@iddic.UUCP (05/02/84)

I am interested in the recent flaming about refined sugar, especially the

parts about references.  Just because somebody has an M. D. degree (or is a

Nobel Laureate) and has written a book DOES NOT make them an expert, OR mean

that their 'research' is valid.  Nutrition seems to be a 'soft' science (even

though it really shouldn't be) - people's opinions are paramount.  One factor

often neglected is that different races and individuals MAY have

significant differences in their metabolisms; for example, I have read of some

problems that Southwestern American Indians have with diabetes and obesity.

I am not saying refined or raw sugar is good or bad, just be careful of the

'I read it in a book by a doctor, so it must be true' mentality.

						Rick Coates
						tektronix!iddic!rickc

sed408@ihlpg.UUCP (s. dugan) (07/26/85)

> >Sugar is not physically addicting, either, as far as I know.
> 
> Neither are coffee and cigarettes physically addictive.  Sugar, like caffene
> and nicotene IS habit forming.  And all three are unnecessary.
> 
Caffeine and nicotine (note spellings) NOT physically addictive??????  Then why do
people go through physical withdrawal when quitting smoking and/or coffee?  I think
you better check your definition of "physical addiction"!


-- 

Sarah E. Dugan
"Thank God It's Friday."

###########################################################################
# AT&T Bell Labs IH 1D-408                The Forest (home)               #
# Naperville-Wheaton Rd.                  1353 Crab Apple Court  Apt. 101 #
# Naperville, Illinois  60566             Naperville, Illinois  60540     #
# (312) 979 - 5545                        (312) 355 - 0445                #
###########################################################################

sed408@ihlpg.UUCP (s. dugan) (07/26/85)

To update my own article, please consider the following definitions found in the
Random House College Dictionary.  I realize this in not a medical dictionary.  I
would like to see some similar definitions from a medical dictionary.

"addicted"  -  devoted or given up to a practice or habit or to something
habit-forming, as a narcotic, cigarettes, etc.
                              ^^^^^^^^^^

"addiction"  -  the state of being addicted, esp. to a habit-forming drug, to such
an extent that cessation causes severe trauma.


-- 

Sarah E. Dugan
"Thank God It's Friday."

###########################################################################
# AT&T Bell Labs IH 1D-408                The Forest (home)               #
# Naperville-Wheaton Rd.                  1353 Crab Apple Court  Apt. 101 #
# Naperville, Illinois  60566             Naperville, Illinois  60540     #
# (312) 979 - 5545                        (312) 355 - 0445                #
###########################################################################