[net.rec.bridge] hand 3 from bidding contest B4

rainbow@ihuxe.UUCP (08/30/84)

  
"E"-comments from the experts
"C"-comments from the contestants
"R"-comments from me
*******************************************************************
Hand 3:                N    E    S    W    Vul:NS
                       -    -    2C   P        matchpoints
S:AK864               2D(1) 5C   ? 
H:A
D:AK9732              (1)negative
C:A

6C...6 experts...2 contestants...10 points
pass.4...........0................9.......
dbl..2...........5................8.......
5NT..1...........0................8.......
5D...1...........4................8.......
6D...1...........1................8.......

*******************************************************************
C:Anything could be right. Best guess is 6D. If opponents sack in 6H,
  continue with 6S.
E:6D is too unilateral.
R:spades could be the better contract.

C:5D should make.
E:5D does leave more room for the possibility that you will get to show
  your second suit.
R:Slam seems fairly certain. Playing only in game is not good.

C:dbl. Bidding on is shooting craps. Down four for 700 is realistic if game
  is on.
E:It's hard to believe that trying for 700 on this type of hand wins bridge
    tournaments.
E:It's hard to justify a bid whose ultimate goal is an average board.
R:It does appear to me that there should be a slam somewhere in all 
  probability.

C:6C. This is matchpoints. You must find the major suit if possible.
  Raise 6D to 7D. Raise 6S to 7S. Convert 6H to 6S implying diamonds.
R:Well done cadomin!judy.
E:6C. Hard to imagine a hand that won't have a play for six. Pass 6D.
  Correct 6H to 6S.
E:Gives the best shot to finding the right spot.
R:You might end up playing in spades when diamonds is right, ie 2-5-3-3.

E:pass. Anything else at this point is a guess. Partner is now forced to bid
  and hopefully this will clear things up a little.
E:pass. Bid 6D over partner's action(dbl). This implies a two-suiter. 
  Partner will correct when its right. A direct 6D call implies a one suiter.
R:this seems to work out real well.

By the way, for those who questioned the 2D call, in standard bidding it
shows a weak hand of about 0 to 7 points.