[net.politics] El Salvador

kh (03/15/83)

   "Crossfire", a show on the Cable News Network, last week had a show
about El Salvador.  The guest was an expert on guerrilla warfare.  I
found many of his opinions surprising, considering that he was a member
of the Conservative Caucus. First of all, he said that the army of
El Salvador was badly led, with mostly corrupt leaders (though he
did cite a few exceptions), and was using bad strategy for the type of
war that was going on. The army also suffers from bad morale; the army
of Guatemala was much better in each of these categories according to
his experience.

   He seemed to know what he was talking about and had visited El Salvador
five times in recent years, so it wasn't just ivory-tower research. He
said that additional military advisors were not necessary, but that a
civilian staff would allow those already in El Salvador to spend more
time training and less time with their many other duties.  Still, he
admitted that a purely military solution was unlikely to be easy or
produce permanent results.

   His most surprising suggestion was that a cease-fire should be
negotiated with the rebels and peace-keeping forces from the Organization
of American States should be used to insure that the upcoming elections
would be fair and that everyone would have a chance to participate.
I've read in other places that negotiating with the rebels was hard to
defend politically in El Salvador, it being considered tantamount to
surrendering. Pope John Paul II's remarks during his visit there may
have made it more acceptable.

   Personally, I've always wondered why the United States always goes
for such short-sighted military "solutions" to conflicts in foreign countries.
The government that is saved isn't likely to last long, and the anti-
American and communist forces are going to gain support.  It's no wonder
that the revolutionaries are turning to Cuba and the Soviet Union for aid;
What choice do they have when they're fighting a superpower? (Not that I'm
implying that there aren't genuine communists and socialists fighting.)
We helped overthrow the Mossadegh government in Iran in 1953, so now we
end up with a fanatical, virulently anti-American government. It was
inevitable.

					Kenny Hirsch
					duke!unc!kh
					kh.unc@UDel-Relay
					Chapel Hill, N.C.