[net.politics] "life over liberty

wex@ittvax.UUCP (Alan Wexelblat) (08/10/83)

Martin Taylor claims that the importance of living is greater than the
importance of liberty.  He quotes "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness"
as though it were a rank ordering.  This leads to two criticisms from
my view:

1) Is he willing to give up all his liberties merely in order to live?  This is
   not living, it's sheer survival.

2) If the founders of America beleived as you say they did, to whom shall we
   attribute the slogans:  "Give me liberty, or give me death"  and   "Live
   free or die"?

--Alan Wexelblat
decvax!ittvax!wex

kramer@utcsrgv.UUCP (Bryan M. Kramer) (08/11/83)

If you are alive you can always hope for freedom and work to bring it
about, if not for yourself, then for your descendants.

A dead person has no freedom what so ever.

Anyone who espouses "live free or die" must be insane.