[net.politics] Empires: History Question

mat@hou5d.UUCP (11/03/83)

Being caught up in arguments and questions, etc about Grenada and Cuba
and the USSR, I got to wondering.  The USSR is known for oppressing its
people as well as the people of the lads that it rules by might and terror.
Food shortages are the order of the day in the USSR and its satellites;
alchohlism is said to be rampant, ... .

Question is, did other large empires in history face these problems in the
chronic fashion that the Soviet Union does?  Has lightr-speed communications
made Soviet mismanagement more effective (?) than the management/mismanagement
of the empires of Ghengis Khan or the Caesers or Napoleon (who was supposed to
have been a masterful logistician) or ... ?

						Kind of wondering,
						Mark Terribile
						hou5d!mat
						Duke Of deNet

notes@fortune.UUCP (11/08/83)

#R:hou5d:-72900:fortune:17300007:000:197
fortune!norskog    Nov  7 17:54:00 1983

The Soviet Union is the first empire in history which supplies its
satellites, rather than the other way around.  It is squandering its
vast but mismanaged resources on small mismanaged colonies.

mmt@dciem.UUCP (Martin Taylor) (11/16/83)

=====
The Soviet Union is the first empire in history which supplies its
satellites, rather than the other way around.  It is squandering its
vast but mismanaged resources on small mismanaged colonies.
=====
References, please? I had the impression that the USSR was bleeding
its European satellites pretty badly, not to mention Russia taking advantage
of the rest of the Soviet Union.

Martin Taylor

eich@uiuccsb.UUCP (11/20/83)

#R:hou5d:-72900:uiuccsb:11000061:000:1018
uiuccsb!eich    Nov 17 11:15:00 1983

/***** uiuccsb:net.politics / fortune!notes /  9:50 pm  Nov  8, 1983 */
The Soviet Union is the first empire in history which supplies its
satellites, rather than the other way around.  It is squandering its
vast but mismanaged resources on small mismanaged colonies.
/* ---------- */

Wrong.  The Soviets, through such tricks as the `transferable ruble'
that they foisted on the Poles a few years back, which was undervalued
by 30% in the terms of the agreement and was not transferable, have
been siphoning off the fruits of their satellites' production.  Some
rural Polish communist party officials reported this a few months
before martial law.  The particular result was an unnatural scarcity
(Polish farmers would only produce enough food for their own needs,
because there were no goods to buy with profit from surplus effort);
this compounded the usual dreary performance of planned economies
in the east (Hungary is an exception, owing to economic liberalization),
and helped contribute to Solidarity's rise.