[net.games.video] Atari 5200 Review

jjm (11/29/82)

I bought an ATARI 5200 "SUPERSYSTEM" this weekend.  It is available
in several major stores in New Jersey - best price I found was at
TOYS R US in Woodbridge - $199.97 (includes console, two controllers,
power supply, antenna/game switch box, and SUPER BREAKOUT cartridge.

Physical design is very nice - console includes covered storage bin
for the controllers.  Switch box supplies signal and power connections
between the console + TV.  Power supply seems sturdier than before, with
longer cord.  Switch box switches from antenna to game when console is
powered up.  Controllers are true proportional joysticks - a major
improvement!  Controllers contain game select, reset, start, and pause
buttons - the only console switch is ON/OFF power switch.

Game play of SUPER BREAKOUT is OK.  I'm surprised that they include a
game that so poorly demonstrates the abilities of the new system.
MISSILE COMMAND (my only other cartridge) is EXCELLENT!
Trakball will be available soon, but with a real joystick it is not 
necessary.

Overall impression: I'm glad I bought it, and I intend to buy the
2600 converter when it comes out so I can play my old ATARI games...

rjf (03/08/83)

	I've had an Atari 5200 now since Christmas, and basically have been
    very pleased with its performance.  The graphics are very good and the
    games available have been good and seem to be getting even better.
    I've played the Intellivision and Colecovision units and feel that it is
    definitely better than the Intellivision.  It is as good as the
    Colecovision unit, although there currently is a better selection of games
    for the Colecovision.  My main gripes consist of the following:

		1) Need more selection in games available.
		2) Joystick contollers should be self-centering.
		3) Where is the Trak-ball controller they promised?
		4) Where is the 2600 adapter that Colecovision ALREADY has?

    All but (2) above should change eventually, the question is when.  Of
    the currently available game cartridges, this is how I rate them:

		Missle Command		very good
		Space Invaders		don't have, why bother?
		Super Breakout		okay, nothing great
		Star Raiders		excellent
		Centipede		good, but really needs Trak-Ball
		Countermeasure		very good, different
		Pac-Man			good, but can get boring
		Galaxian		very good, but can get boring

    More and different cartridges are needed.  I'm hoping that other game
    makers will jump on the 5200 bandwagon, just like they did with the 2600.
    The above are the cartridges that I know about, if you disagree with my
    ratings or know of any other cartridges out or rumors of any to be put
    out, let me know.  I'm looking forward to Qix and others in the near
    future.

		Bob Fabrizio
		...!decvax!mcnc!rlgvax!rjf
		...!seismo!rlgvax!rjf

??? (03/09/83)

Bob... thanks for the review.  Here in Denver it is hard to find
some of the cartridges that are available elsewhere.  I can't 
seem to find Centipede, Pac-Man or Defender anywhere!

In response to your four gripes, here are some comments:

1) "Need more selection in games available."
	- Because the 5200 isn't a widespread product (yet), smaller
	  software companies may not be able to afford to produce
	  cartridges for it.  Those with foresight should be ready,
	  though.  I predict that Activision and Imagic will produce
	  software for the 5200 after there is a larger base of 5200
	  units.  We may see software from companies that are already
	  producing Atari 400/800 cartridges before the 2600 vendors,
	  since conversion to the 5200 is minimal.

2) "Joystick controllers should be self-centering."
	- This is a matter of preference.  The game being played
	  should also be considered.  For instance, I think Missle
	  Command plays much better without self-centering.  For
	  most games, I prefer the non-centering joystick.  As the
	  system catches on, joystick alternatives should pop up.

3) "Where is the Trak-ball controller they promised?"
4) "Where is the 2600 adapter that Colecovision ALREADY has?"
	- Atari is famous for teasing us gamers that are drooling
	  at the thought of more software and more hardware!  I
	  usually add 1 to 3 months to any announcement for new
	  Atari software, and 3 to 9 months to any announcement
	  for new hardware.  Things are even worse now, since the
	  5200 is just getting out.

Us 5200 owners will just have to suffer until Atari gets into full
production and until the 5200 "proves" itself.  Intellivision and
Colecovision may have beaten Atari to the punch with voice synthesis,
2600 adapters and software, but in the long run the 5200 will be more
popular.  The Intellivision and Colecovision controllers are awful
(flames to /dev/null), and only because of expense.  The game units
are not as solid as the 5200, either.  What I would like to see is
an optional RGB output so graphics could be as crystal clear as a 
real arcade.  I hear that it is simple to tap into the RGB signal
with simple modification to any video game.  Converting a standard
TV to accept RGB input is another story, although kits are available
for this purpose.

Ray Davis   ABI Denver CC   31y31   (303)451-3991   decvax!harpo!druxy!rbd