[net.startrek] Spock's smarts in "Menagerie"

rjnoe@ihlts.UUCP (Roger Noe @ N41:48:31, W88:07:13) (02/01/84)

>Why was it logical to risk so much to get Captain Christoper Pike
>back to that planet?

Because not allowing Pike to have the use of his body was a waste of human
potential.  "A mind is a terrible thing to waste . . ."  He also knew he
could not fail.
	Roger Noe		ihnp4!ihlts!rjnoe

rjnoe@ihlts.UUCP (Roger Noe @ N41:48:31, W88:07:13) (02/09/84)

>>	Oh come on...  what waste of human material?  On his new planet Pike
>>	can't *DO* ANY MORE than he could anywhere else...  He just *thinks*
>>	he can...
>>					mike stanley

True, but are you sure there's a difference?  Maybe you cannot DO anything
at all, maybe you just THINK you can.  If the "illusion" is perfect, you
cannot tell the difference between what you believe and "reality".  If you
have a clear understanding of reality and illusion, if you are certain that
you physically exist, then I congratulate you for your certainty.  But I do
not applaud you for it because such certainty makes you less human than
the terminal I am typing on.  True self-awareness implies SOME doubt of
one's own sense perceptions.  Further discussion really belongs in
net.philosophy, but this IS one of the things I had hoped we could discuss
in net.startrek.  Thanks for an interesting discussion.
	Roger Noe		ihnp4!ihlts!rjnoe