[net.startrek] Vulcan Language

tiberio@seismo.UUCP (Mike Tiberio) (03/15/84)

Recent activity in this news group has caused me to review my ST I and II
video tapes. One thing began to bother me recently and that is, why
would conversation in a language like Vulcan, which I assume has a 
richer phoenetic base than english, take the same number of syllables
as english. From what I know about the way the create extra terrestrial
spoken languages in the movies, I can only assume the take the English
and scramble the syllables, resulting in the same number. Is my assumption
about the Vulcan spoken language unreasonable?

ty

martillo@ihuxt.UUCP (Yehoyaqim Shemtob Martillo) (03/16/84)

Phonetic richness has nothing to do with number of syllables.  Arabic is
much richer than English phonetically.  Yet if a person says a passage in
English and then translates the passage into Arabic, the translation will
have fewer syllables.