[net.startrek] Was Menagerie the pilot?

lorien@dartvax.UUCP (Lorien Y. Pratt) (05/22/84)

I seem to remember reading somewhere that Menagerie was the pilot for
Star Trek.  However, after seeing it last night, it seems more likely
that the story spock shows on the display screen during his trial is
actually culled from the pilot show.

What's the answer?

      --Lorien Y. Pratt
	Dartmouth College Library
	Hanover, NH  03755

	decvax!dartvax!lorien

burton@inuxg.UUCP (Thomas Burton) (05/23/84)

xx <- two-footed bug stomp!

No! No! No! (to the article that said the Cage was the first
pilot and the Menagerie was the second pilot).

The Cage was indeed the first pilot. The Menagerie was a two
part episode made later which incorporated parts of the Cage.
"Where No Man has Gone Before" was the second pilot, and
McCoy was not the doctor (can't remember the name of the
Doctor or the actor's name).


			Doug Burton
			ATT-CP Indianapolis
			inuxg!burton

friedman@uiucdcs.UUCP (05/23/84)

#R:dartvax:-164800:uiucdcs:24900039:000:349
uiucdcs!friedman    May 23 11:08:00 1984

The first ST pilot was called "The Cage".  It was never broadcast as such.
GR often shows a black-and-white print of it when he lectures; he says that
no color print of it survives.  Most of "The Cage" (with a few missing scenes
and a slightly different ending) was used in "Menagerie" as the story shown
on the display screen during Spock's trial.

jrb@wdl1.UUCP (jrb ) (05/25/84)

#R:dartvax:-164800:wdl1:2700001:000:170
wdl1!jrb    May 24 14:10:00 1984

WRONG!!!!!!!!  The second pilot was _Where No Man Has Gone Before_.




				John R Blaker
				UUCP:	...!fortune!wdl1!jrb
				ARPA:	jrb@FORD-WDL1
				and	blaker@FORD-WDL2