[net.startrek] A short spirited defense

wix@bergil.DEC (Jack Wickwire) (06/27/84)

This is being forwarded through me to NET.STARTREK. I only do some basic 
formatting and I am not responsible for its content. All responses sent 
to me will be forwarded to the author. 

Is there any reason for a * * ** SPOILER WARNING ** * * now?

	"The Star Trek series always appealed to me because it seemed
	to emphasize reason, compassion, and sensibility over
	violence and brutality.  Perhaps I'm getting overly
	sensitive in my old age, but this last flick left a bad
	taste in my mouth."
 
		--Rich Ganns
 
For heaven's sake, how much reason and compassion do you expect?
Kirk tried to reason with Kruge before they began fighting; he
exhibited compassion when Kruge was hanging from the edge of
the cliff:  he said, "Give me your hand", and got grabbed by the
foot and half dragged over the cliff for his trouble.  Do you
really think that Kirk's allowing himself to be dragged over
the cliff with Kruge would be a blow struck for sensibility?
 
 
*Uhura's name*
 
Diane Duane uses "Nyota" as Uhura's first name in her two
"Star Trek" novels.  I don't know where she got this.
 
 
*For Josie Clementz*
 
Here's the only non-fan's reaction to STIII that I have.
You'll have to make slight allowances for a sardonic turn
of expression and the desire to tease a Trekkie.
 
	"We both enjoyed *Trek III*, I blush to admit.
	I mean, for dumb skiffy stuff, it wasn't bad.
	Lots of nice little bits of humor, and they
	killed the stupid son, and they blew up the
	Enterprise (I was the only one in the theatre
	who applauded), and the new Vulcan is cuter
	than the old one, even if she's not as convincing
	in the role."
   --------