[net.micro.68k] Is the 68000 overrated?

grunwald (10/22/82)

#R:populi:-38400:uiucdcs:23900011:000:936
uiucdcs!grunwald    Oct 21 18:31:00 1982

  Well, I was partially wrong. You can use a 'CMPA' instruction to test an
address register, but that requires a total of 12 bytes to test a register
for NIL.

However, I don't think that that sways the argument very much. I feel that the
people at Motorola did a fantastic job with the 68000, but I don't think that
it is the end-all of micro-processors.

As someone else noted (either here or in net.micro), a lot of bells and
whistles don't really make for a fast machine. According to the Aug. Computer
magizine, some people who had not done IC design before developed a RISC
(reduced instruction-set computer) which would seem to have very fast
performance. It only had about 30 instructions, but when one thinks about it,
how many does that typical compiler use? I would much perfer that the
instruction set be totally orthogonal and not have those little gems like the
'MOVEP' instruction that the 68K has.


						dirk grunwald