[net.physics] Projective formulation of force

lew@ihuxr.UUCP (09/30/83)

One really neat application of projective coordinates is the unified
description of force and torque by a "bound vector". If a and b are the
projective coordinates of two fixed points. The antisymmetric tensor
product (wedge product), a^b represents the line through a and b. The
equation for points x on the line is: a^b^x = 0. Nice huh? Of course,
the equation of a plane defined by a,b, and c is a^b^c^x = 0. a^b
has six components:

	(a1*b2-a2*b1, a1*b3-a3*b1, ..., a3*b4-a4*b3)

For points not at infinity, we can pick the canonical coordinates

	(a1,a2,a3,a4) == (1,ax,ay,az)

The components of a^b then become:

	(bx-ax, by-ay, bz-az, ax*by-ay*bx, ax*bz-az*bx, ay*bz-az*by)

This represents a "bound vector", the first three components are the
components of the usual displacement, or "free vector". The second three
describe the moment of the free vector about the origin. This binds the
vector to lie along a certain line, namely the line a^b.

This bound vector can describe a force and its moment, a couple. These
form a linear space, since the resultant force and torque of a set
of couples is their sum. HOWEVER, not every resultant can be produced by
the action of a single force. For example, pure torques require at least
two forces. If (E12,E13,E14,E23,E24,E34) are the coordinates of an arbitrary
couple, the criterion that a single force can produce it is given by
the PLUCKER RELATION (that's PLOO ker: the u has an umlaut):

	E12*E34 - E13*E24 + E14*E23 = 0

The thing I like about this example is that it shows that our usual
formulation of forces is not the only one possible. It makes it clear that
a force is not a physical thing but rather a mathematical abstraction. You
could argue that the bound vector description is really more "natural" since
equivalent couples produce equivalent results.

The stuff about forces and couples is in Felix Klein's Geometry book
that I mentioned before. I learned about Plucker relations from one
of my favorite books of all time, "Vector Spaces of Finite Dimension",
by G. C. Shephard. This is a beautifully concise little book published by
University Mathematical Texts (from England). It touches on topics that
the typical undergraduate linear algebra text never gets near, even
though it's about one fifth the length.

	Lew Mammel, Jr. ihuxr!lew