[net.physics] summary of sunrise phenomenon responses

pagiven@drutx.UUCP (GivenP) (11/05/84)

                                 -
Thanks to all who replied to "Sunrise Phenomenon."

Briefly, netters were asked if they could explain the "rosy fingers
of  dawn:"  on a cloudless morning, shafts of alternating deep blue
and orange light radiating from the horizon  just  before  sunrise.
Can it happen at sunset, too?

Summary of responses:

  1.  Yes, it has been observed to happen at sunset by at least one
      respondent.

  2.  The orange light is caused by atmospheric refraction,  as  we
      observe at the usual sunrise or sunset.

  3.  The light appears in shafts because of  either  cloudmass  or
      terrain  irregularities that lie beyond the horizon and block
      some of the refracted red light.

  4.  Although the sky appears cloudless, it really has a thin haze
      of  cirrus  clouds that act as a "movie screen" upon which is
      projected shafts of  light  caused  by  sunrise  over  either
      irregular  terrain  or  cumulus clouds. Perspective gives the
      illusion of radiating bars.

  5.  The blue light is there because the  strongly  refracted  red
      light  is blocked thereby letting the observer see the weakly
      refracted blue light.

  6.  The horizon must be far enough  away  from  the  observer  to
      allow  refracted light to reach, thus the phenomenon is never
      observed at sunset from Denver: the mountainous western  hor-
      izon  is  too  close.  Nor is it observed if the cloudmass is
      above the horizon.

The common thread in these explanations seems to be the requirement
of  irregular  terrain  or cloudmass just beyond the horizon.  I am
reminded of the  solar  eclipse  phenomenon  where  sunlight  peers
through lunar surface asperity, is it called "Bailey's Beads?"

However, none of the explanations deal with the *striking* regular-
ity  and  even  spacing  of those bars of light!  Random chance? or
slipshod observing?  Nor do the proffered explanations address  the
phenomenon's  rarity.   If unchanging irregular terrain and a clear
sky are all that is required, why do we not see it more often?  (at
least  for those of us foolish enough to be up at such a ridiculous
hour :-))

 -----------------------------------------------------------------
 Paul Given             {ihnp4, houxe, stcvax!ihnp4}!drutx!pagiven
              AT&T Information Systems Laboratories
 11900 N. Pecos, Rm 1B04, Denver 80234              (303)-538-4058
 -----------------------------------------------------------------