[net.physics] The monkey problem...

wasser@viking.DEC (John A. Wasser) (10/30/85)

> 
>A [massless] Rope passes over a [frictionless, massless] Pulley.  On one side
>is a Weight [n Kg].  On the other side, level with the Weight, is a Monkey, 
>also weighing n Kg.  Both the Monkey and the Weight are initially at rest.  
>The Monkey [as you might have guessed by now] starts climbing the Rope.  What
>is the motion of the Weight [or for that matter, that of the Monkey]?
>
	When the monkey pulls on the rope, the upward force applied to
	both the weight and the monkey is the same.  Since they have
	the same mass they will accelerate upward together at the same
	rate and decelerate at the same rate due to gravity [There is a
	mass below them, isn't there? :-)]  The result is that the weight
	and the monkey rise at the same rate.
 
>What if the Pulley is not frictionless?  

	The monkey will rise faster than the weight because some of the
	upward force that would be applied to the mass has been lost
	fighting pulley friction.  At the limit of friction (infinite
	friction in the pulley) the weight would remain stationary as
	the monkey climbs.

>What if the Rope is not massless?

	As soon as the weight starts up, the additional mass of the rope
	on the monkey side will cause the monkey to accelerate downward
	and the weight to accelerate upward.  Assuming the rope is
	infinitely long, the weight will eventually reach the speed of
	light in it's upward travel and the monkey will be dropping
	at the same speed.  At that point, if he hasn't reached the 
	top, he never will.

		-John A. Wasser

Work address:
ARPAnet:	WASSER%VIKING.DEC@decwrl.ARPA
Usenet:		{allegra,Shasta,decvax}!decwrl!dec-rhea!dec-viking!wasser
Easynet:	VIKING::WASSER
Telephone:	(617)486-2505
USPS:		Digital Equipment Corp.
		Mail stop: LJO2/E4
		30 Porter Rd
		Littleton, MA  01460