[net.games.pbm] Fall '01 Turn Results...

myers@uwmacc.UUCP (Jeff Myers) (02/18/85)

A for Army, F for Fleet, (SC) for South Coast, (NC) for North Coast.
Failed moves are in [], final postions are in CAPS.

Builds:		none.

Fall, 1901 Moves --

England:	[F NORTH SEA-denmark], F NORWEGIAN SEA convoys
		A edinburgh-NORWAY
		** 1 Build **
Germany:	[A KIEL-denmark], A ruhr-BELGIUM, [F HOLLAND-north sea]
		** 1 Build **
Russia:		F gulf of bothnia-SWEDEN, A silesia-MUNICH, A ukraine-RUMANIA,
		F BLACK SEA supports A ukraine-rumania
		** 3 Builds **
Turkey:		[A BULGARIA-serbia], [F CONSTANTINOPLE-bulgaria(sc)],
		A smyrna-ANKARA
		** 1 Build **
Austria-Hun.:	Civil Disorder, F ALBANIA holds, A SERBIA holds,
		A GALICIA holds
		** 1 Lost **
Italy:		F ionian sea-TUNIS, A trieste-VIENNA, A venice-TRIESTE
		** 3 Builds **
France:		F mid-atlantic ocean-IRISH SEA, A spain-PORTUGAL,
		A gascony-SPAIN
		** 2 Builds **

Next move should be mailed by 02/24/85.

david@fisher.UUCP (David Rubin) (02/21/85)

More kibbitzing material!

> Fall, 1901 Moves --
> 
> England:	[F NORTH SEA-denmark], F NORWEGIAN SEA convoys
> 		A edinburgh-NORWAY
> 		** 1 Build **

And they trusted the French!  At least the political situation does
not leave England isolated; he will have a useful ally in Russia
(though he is likely to be Russia's SECOND favorite ally).  With
Russian cooperation, Denmark will still fall, and Franco-German
attacks are unlikely to really tell before Germany begins a serious
collapse.  England, however, will be on the defensive for quite a
while.

> Germany:	[A KIEL-denmark], A ruhr-BELGIUM, [F HOLLAND-north sea]
> 		** 1 Build **

The Franco-German alliance is a noble gamble, though it might have
been wiser to turn French attentions southwards and enlist England as
an ally (offering him Scandinavia).  Still, Germany can regain Munich,
has a valuable friend (though he will sorely feel the vacuum on the
Danube), and will lead an exciting life...

> Russia:		F gulf of bothnia-SWEDEN, A silesia-MUNICH, A ukraine-RUMANIA,
> 		F BLACK SEA supports A ukraine-rumania
> 		** 3 Builds **

Russia grows exponentially!  An impressive, albeit tenuous, display.
It is doubtful that the Russians can hold Munich, but they can make
life very interesting for all by retreating (when the time comes) to
the Ruhr, or Burgundy.  This will drive the opposing alliance up the
wall.

> Turkey:		[A BULGARIA-serbia], [F CONSTANTINOPLE-bulgaria(sc)],
> 		A smyrna-ANKARA
> 		** 1 Build **

Tactical error.  Even if the low probability move to Serbia were to
succeed, Bulgaria could be picked up at liesure; moreover, the
probability was much better for a move to Greece.  Either way, Turkey
squandered the initiative by failing to order F Con -> Aeg, and now
Italy may have gotten the means to punish such an error.

> Austria-Hun.:	Civil Disorder, F ALBANIA holds, A SERBIA holds,
> 		A GALICIA holds
> 		** 1 Lost **

Poor sport.  If the Austrians can't win, they evidently will take
their pail and go home.

> Italy:		F ionian sea-TUNIS, A trieste-VIENNA, A venice-TRIESTE
> 		** 3 Builds **

Austrian anemia has turned what would have otherwise been a terrible
blunder into a brilliance; Rome is richly rewarded by Vienna's lack
of righteous anger.  Instead of being steamrolled by the Eastern
powers, Italy will likely be near a match for Turkey and whatever
Russian forces are available.  This may tempt the Tsar into
cooperating with the Italians rather than the Turks.

> France:		F mid-atlantic ocean-IRISH SEA, A spain-PORTUGAL,
> 		A gascony-SPAIN
> 		** 2 Builds **

A bit premature, I'd say.  France cannot yet threaten a convoy, and
England can build in Liverpool.  I don't see why this could not have
waited at least until Spring 1902 (perhaps even better, 1903), when
either an army could be landed in Wales or Clyde or even Liverpool
in the Fall.  England would certainly have built on the North Sea had
France given them the opportunity.

Overall:  Some astute diplomacy by Germany (goading the French attack)
puts them right back in the pack.  Austrian character deficiencies
turn Italy's position into one of the strongest from one of the
weakest.  Turkey loses some steam.  Russia makes a flashy, albeit
superficial, showing.  England is surprised.  France's timing could
use improvement.

					David Rubin

myers@uwmacc.UUCP (Jeff Myers) (02/27/85)

> 
> > Austria-Hun.:	Civil Disorder, F ALBANIA holds, A SERBIA holds,
> > 		A GALICIA holds
> > 		** 1 Lost **
> 
> Poor sport.  If the Austrians can't win, they evidently will take
> their pail and go home.
> 

A Hasty Conclusion.  Austria was nabbed by the Usenet.

jeff myers, moderator, game # Myers1

PS.  For game identification, why don't we use the moderators last name
concatenated with a number of that moderators own choosing.