[net.suicide] Hesse on Suicides

vax1:swifty (03/08/83)

from The Steppenwolf, by Hermann Hesse

	"...Here it must be said that to call suicides only those who
actually destroy themselves is false.  Among these, indeed, there are
many who in a sense are only suicides by accident and in whose being
suicide has no necessary place. Among the common run of men there are
many of little personality and stamped with no deep impress of fate,
who find their end in suicide without belonging on that account to the
type of the suicide by inclination; while on the other hand, of those
who are to be counted as suicides by the very nature of their beings
are many, perhaps a majority, who never in fact lay hands on
themselves.  The "suicide," and Harry was one, need not necessarily live
in a peculiarly close relationship to death.  One may do this without
being a suicide.  What is peculiar to the suicide is that his ego,
rightly or wrongly, is felt to be an extremely dangerous, dubious, and
doomed germ of nature; that he is always in his own eyes exposed to an
extraordinary risk, as though he stood with the slightest foothold on
the peak of a crag whence a slight push from without or an instant's
weakness from within suffices to precipitate him into the void.  The
line of fate in the case of these men is marked by the belief they have
that suicide is their most probable manner of death.  It might be
presumed that such temperments, which usually manifest themselves in
early youth and persist through life, show a singular defect of vital
force.  On the contrary, among "suicides" are to be found unusually
tenacious and eager and also hardy natures.  But just as there are
those who at the least indisposition develop a fever, so do those we
call suicides, and who are always very emotional and sensitive, develop
at the least shock the notion of suicide.  Had we a science with the
courage and authority to concern itself with mankind, instead of the
mechanism merely of vital phenomena, had we something of the nature of
an anthropology, or a psychology, these matters of fact would be
familiar to every one.
	"What was said above on the subject of suicides touches
obviously nothing but the surface.  It is psychology, and, therefore,
partly physics.  Metaphysically considered, the matter has a different
and a much clearer aspect. In this aspect suicides present themselves
as those who are overtaken by the sense of guilt inherent in
individuals, those souls that find the aim of life not in the
perfecting and molding of the self, but in liberating themselves by
going back to the mother, back to God, back to the all.  Many of these
natures are wholly incapable of ever having recourse to real suicide,
because they have a profound consciousness of the sin of doing so.  For
us they are suicides nonetheless; for they see death and not life as
the releaser.  They are ready to cast themselves away in surrender, to
be extinguished and to go back to the beginning.
	"As every strength may become a weakness (and under some
circumstances must) so, on the contrary, may the typical suicide find
strength and support in his apparent weakness.  Indeed, he does so more
often than not.  The case of Harry, the Steppenwolf, is one of these.
As thousands of his like do, he found consolation and support, and not
merely the melancholy play of youthful fancy, in the idea that the way
to death was open to him at any moment.  It is true that with him, as
with all men of his kind, every shock, every pain, every untoward
predicament at once called forth the wish to find an escape in death.
By degrees, however, he fashioned for himself out of this tendency a
philosophy that was actually serviceable to life.  He gained strength
through familiarity with the thought that the emergency exit stood
always open, and become curious, too, to taste his suffering to the
dregs.  If it went too badly with him he could feel sometimes with a
grim malicious pleasure:  'I am curious to see all the same just how
much a man can endure.  If the limit of what is bearable is reached, I
have only to open the door to escape.'  There are a great many suicides
to whom this thought imparts an uncommon strength.
	"On the other hand, all suicides have the responsibility of
fighting against the temptation of suicide.  Every one of them knows
very well in some corner of his soul that suicide, though a way out, is
a rather mean and shabby one, and that it is nobler and finer to be
conquered by life than to fall by one's own hand.  Knowing this, with a
morbid conscience whose source is much the same as that of the militant
conscience of so-called self-contented persons, the majority of
suicides are left to a protracted struggle against their temptations."



Steve Swift (swifty)
Seattle, WA