[net.suicide] Orphaned Response

mark (03/22/83)

#R:zinfandel:11700009:zinfandel:11700021:177600:106
zinfandel!mark    Mar 19 23:23:00 1983

I'd be rather surprised if Thoreau did know of any fox suicides
even if there were some.

Mark Wittenberg

mark (03/22/83)

#R:zinfandel:11700009:zinfandel:11700023:000:25
zinfandel!mark    Mar 20 13:22:00 1983

Touche'

Mark Wittenberg

jack@hp-dcd.UUCP (06/05/83)

#R:hao:0:hp-dcd:6200001:37777777600:334
hp-dcd!jack    Jun  3 10:31:00 1983

	".. it seems that a person who felt there was no
	purpose for their continued existence would hardly feel
	they had anything to say.  What purpose would a note
	serve to them?"

They could write a note explaining the pressures that caused them
to kill themselves in the hope that others would read the note
and try to change things.

judy@ism780.UUCP (04/20/84)

#R:hpfclk:-730065608:ism780:18100001:177600:1791
ism780!judy    Apr 18 15:21:00 1984

Mike,

Please be careful.  You are falling into the trap of assuming everyone
is like you.  You cannot generalized depression by what makes you, an
obviously intelligent and "sane" person, mildly depressed for a day.

Clinical depression is a mental illness.  It is fairly mild as mental
illnesses go (consider schizophrenia).  However, there are some very
severe, fatal cases of it.  Consider for a moment a child.  At age one
her father abandons her.  Her mother goes crazy and tries to kill both
the child and herself.  The child is reared in a religous household in
which all medical assistance is denied.  In response to a broken arm
she is told it is just her imagination.  She
is tortured and raped by an older male relative.

Now, do you seriously think that if she felt better about her work and like
more of a productive member of society she would feel all better.  WRONG!
This kind of depression has deep and serious roots.  This person is in
deep pain, internally bleeding in an emotional sense.  And there is a time,
perhaps triggered by an outside event, when the pain is too much.  You would
not call the cancer patient selfish for ending her life rather than live
for two years in unbearable pain.  How DARE you so cavalierly dismiss this
womans pain by calling her wish selfish!

Fortunately, there is professional help for people with such mental illnesses
as cronic depression, manic depression, etc.  And the prognosis is high.
But the cost is also high.  It requires feeling all that pain and anger and
humiliation and then learning to live daily with the memories and the pain.

Compasion is the answer to this problem.  Quit blaming and start
understanding.  Imagine, for 30 seconds, what life would feel like as
another human being.  Love, don't judge.

Judy Leedom

paul@uiucuxc.UUCP (11/29/84)

Men tend to use deadlier methods for suicide.  With pills or wrist slashing
there's a chance that not enough was taken, someone will get your message,
cut wasn't deep enough, etc.  Handguns or aiming the car at a bridge support
at 70 mph are less likely to fail.

	 Paul Pomes

UUCP:	 {ihnp4,pur-ee}!uiucdcs!uiucuxc!paul
ARPA:	 paul%uiucuxc%uiuc.csnet@csnet-relay.arpa
CSNET:	 paul%uiucuxc@uiuc
US Mail: Univ of Illinois, CSO, 1304 W Springfield Ave, Urbana, IL  61801

jjm@faust.UUCP (05/29/85)

			 

jad@hpcnoe.UUCP (03/05/86)

> /***** hpcnoe:net.suicide / mit-amt!gerber / 10:12 am  Mar  1, 1986*/

> BJO-B, your reply sounds like an attention-getting ploy so everyone
> can see what a callous jerk you are.

> If you can't say something nice about someone's request for sympathy,
> say nothing.  If someone wants sympathy, and you don't want to give
> it, then SHUT UP.  Don't make them feel worse.

	Gosh, and I was just [fondly] remembering the days when
	net.suicide was hotter than net.flame.  Guess it's gotten a bit
	serious these days (it is a serious subject, but one that's
	awful hard to deal with in a forum like this, seems to me), so
	perhaps I'd best take that advice myself and SHUT UP too ...

					CUL
				--	jad	 --

"The other day they waited, the sky was dark and faded,
 solemnly they stated, "He has to die, you know he has to die."
 All the children learnin', from books that they were burnin',
 every leaf was turnin'; to watch him die, you know he had to die."