[net.audio] Concert Hall Realism

wjm@whuxk.UUCP (10/17/83)

The new (Nov 1983) "Stereo Review" has an interesting article by Julian Hirsch
about concert-hall realism - he says that it is not possible to achieve it 
with even the best home systems.  As usual, he makes an excellent case, and
something to keep in mind when listening to ones system.  Despite the cheap
shots at him (and others in this newsgroup) from certain parties in the Midwest
Hirsch generally has a reasonable perspective about audio.
I agree with him about claims made by the "underground" audio press that
can't seem to be verified in the lab.
There should be an objective quantifiable reason for these differences.
One possibility which has been mentioned here by Steve Bellovin is that there
is a subtle (> .5 dB) difference in loudness between the two items being
compared in the A/B test.
Is Monster Cable, etc. better than plain ordinary wire of the same resistance?
Granted that a speaker is not purely a resistive load, the inductance of the
wire could theoretically have an effect, but since the inductive reactance of
any inductor is directly proportional to the frequency of the signal, its
effect shouldn't be too great at audio frequencies.  It may be worth spending
the $$$ on Monster Cable but first I'd spend it on getting top-of-the-line
equipment and then getting high quality low level interconnecting cables for
phono, tape deck etc to amp, since good cables are more important at the low
level stages of an audio system.
Bill Mitchell
Bell Laboratories
Whippany, NJ  (whuxk!wjm)
P.S. Due to netnews difficulties on whuxk (things seem to get OUT OK, but can't
get IN) I am reading news on gummo, and may start submitting articles from there
I'll still receive mail here, if you wish.