[net.audio] jj's Re: Thoughts on subjectivit

rmd@hpcnoa.UUCP (02/20/84)

I find your comments  about the sound of drums on a CD very  interesting
-- since I thought that even analog proponents  generally  conceded that
digital improved percusion sounds.

Perhaps you could be somewhat  more  specific  about the problem then "I
put my fingers in my ears".  Did you find it too loud, harsh,  distorted
or what?  Which recording was this?

One constructive thing that this endless debate can do is make us think
about the sound a little more and help us become aware of sound qualities
we might otherwise not have noticed.  By being specific and constructive
rather than emotional we might actually learn something.

I  personally  think  drums  sound very good on CDs.  But if you tell me
what you objected to I will certainly  listen for it.  I do believe that
LPs can sometimes  sound  'better'  than CDs.  It doesn't  matter why or
which  sounds  more   lifelike,  only  that  it  sounds  better  to  the
individual.  If you listened to CDs with a more objective  state of mind
maybe you would  start to  appreciate  some of their  qualities.  By the
same logic, if I listened to  direct-to-discs  on Linn  turntables  more
often, maybe I would appreciate more of the qualities of analog sound.

Rick Dow
inhp4!hpfcla!rmd