[net.audio] CD's, 24KHz tones, and sore ears

geoff@callan.UUCP (Geoff Kuenning) (05/10/84)

Forgive me if this has already been pointed out;  I have been short on time
to read this group recently.

Several people have claimed that CD's make their ears hurt.  Those of us who
are rabidly "anti-golden-ear" (like myself) would normally tend to reject any
such suggestion out of hand;  however, I think that this claim is true.

It is appaently not very well-known that the range of human hearing is NOT
simply 20-20K Hz.  In fact, children start out with something more like
15-40K Hz;  both ends deteriorate with age.  Even when you are no longer able
to HEAR some sounds, your ears can still be made sore by loud high-frequency
tones.  I believe this is a lot of the reason why your ears tend to get sore
when listening to high-distortion (read many loud odd overtones above 20KHz)
reproduction.

Where this all relates to CD's is that some CD players apparently produce
a parasitic 24KHZ tone at a fairly high level.  Many high-quality amps and
speakers will reproduce this tone, although possibly distorted.  See the
latest Audio (the special CD issue) for reviews of several culprit players.

So...if CD's make your ears hurt, try listening again with a player that
definitely doesn't produce the 24KHz noise.  You may get a pleasant surprise!

	Geoff Kuenning
	Callan Data Systems
	...!ihnp4!sdcrdcf!trwrb!wlbr!callan!geoff