[net.audio] "Trashy" Absolute Sound

greg@olivej.UUCP (Greg Paley) (09/26/84)

Someone (I can't remember who, maybe someone else on the net
knows) once made the statement that one of the saddest occurences
is when a wise man says something stupid, because it makes
people doubt the validity of all of the wise things he's
previously said.

I feel this way about Absolute Sound.  There are times when
they have indeed been "trashy" in that the individual writers
have indulged in cheap shots, adolescent parodies (such as
their Julian Hearse and David Ramada-Inn jokes), and blanket
condemnations which indicate they've formed a judgement 
without even listening to a product or record.

On the other hand, they also probe into the nature of recorded
and reproduced sound and attempt to provide in-depth evaluations
of equipment in a way that nobody else does.  Following their
advice, I've never been misled into buying a poor piece of
equipment or buying a poor sounding record (although some of
the PERFORMANCES on their recommended list are hardly great).
I have felt misled and angry when following recommendations in
Stereo Review, High Fidelity, and Audio.

	- Greg Paley