[net.audio] Problems with "Disraeli Gears" on CD

mcb@cmu-cs-k.ARPA (Michael Browne) (05/10/85)

I recently purchased a copy of "Disraeli Gears" by Cream on CD, only to find
that there was a loud hiss in the background.  I returned it for another
copy, but this copy hissed also.  After several iterations, I gave up.

Was I just unlucky or is something wrong with this recording?
	--Mike
-- 
uucp: ..!seismo!cmu-cs-k!mcb, or possibly ..!{allegra,ihnp4}!cmucspt!mcb
arpa: mcb@cmu-cs-k.ARPA

jj@alice.UUCP (05/13/85)

"Disraeli Gears" and many other re-releases of old
rock and pop recordings are made from masters that
themselves contain an exorbitant amount of hiss. The
CD process is very good at reproducing that hiss
in a very exact fashion.  The CD process (or any other
linear process, for that matter) cannot remove the noise
(entropy) added to the signal by the original recording
process.    (In fact, if a method for removing
noise from signals were known, it would <ahem>
greately simplify the communications of the world, we would
need only one very noisy wire... :-) )

A sad, but true statement of the disrespect of
the Record (that's vinyl, folks) industry for its
consumers is evident in the old rock motto:
"Don't worry, it's only Rock and Roll, nobody will care
about the hiss as long as it's loud and compressed".


-- 
TEDDY BEARS ARE OPINIONATED! AFTER ALL, SOMEONE HAS TO BE RIGHT!
"Then one said to the other, I think we must be gone,
We'll leave a present for our friend before me move along..."

(ihnp4/allegra)!alice!jj

zadco@ssc-vax.UUCP (Rick Fairfield) (05/17/85)

> I recently purchased a copy of "Disraeli Gears" by Cream on CD, only to find
> that there was a loud hiss in the background.  I returned it for another
> copy, but this copy hissed also.  After several iterations, I gave up.
> 
> Was I just unlucky or is something wrong with this recording?
> 	--Mike
> -- 
> uucp: ..!seismo!cmu-cs-k!mcb, or possibly ..!{allegra,ihnp4}!cmucspt!mcb
> arpa: mcb@cmu-cs-k.ARPA

analog master tape to digital disk = lots of hiss
(i.e. garbage in, garbage out)
							zzzzzadco