[net.math] An interesting identity

lew@ihuxr.UUCP (08/04/83)

I stumbled across the following identity:

	sum i=1 to n of (-1)^(i+1) * C(n,i) * 1/i

		equals

	sum i=1 to n of 1/i

Can anybody provide a reference for this, or show its equivalence to
some basic identity? Surely Euler knew this!

When I tried to prove it inductively by taking S(n+1) - S(n), I got

	sum i=1 to n of (-1)^(i+1) * C(n,i) * 1/(n+1-i)

		equals

	0, n even ; 2/(n+1), n odd

... so this doesn't really help.

	Lew Mammel, Jr. ihuxr!lew

ecn-ec:ecn-pc:ecn-ed:vu@pur-ee.UUCP (08/10/83)

Induction *IS* the way. Then we arrive at:

sum i=1 to n  (-1)^(i+1) *C(n,i) * 1/(n+1-i) equals
  0, n even;
2/(n+1)  n odd.

as equivalent to the given identity.

Now, remark that C(n,i)/(n+1-i)  =  C(n+1, i) / (n+1)

substitute in:

sum i=1 to n  (-1)^(i+1) * C(n+1,i) / (n+1)
	equals
0       n even
2/(n+1) n odd.

Add (-1)^(n+2) / (n+1) both sides:

sum i=1 to (n+1) (-1)^(i+1) * C(n+1,i) / (n+1)
	equals
(-1)^n / (n+1)          n even
( 2 +  (-1)^n ) / (n+1),n odd
	equals
1 / (n+1)    for all n .

Multiply both sides by (n+1), we have that the given identity is
equivalent to:

sum i=1 to (n+1)   (-1)^(i+1) * C(n+1,i)  =  1

Put n' = n+1 and drop the primes:

sum i=1 to n   (-1)^(i+1) * C(n,i)   =   1

This series looks so simple that it has got to be in some elem stat
text. I have not taken any stat course at all, so that I don't know
where it can be found.

Hao-Nhien Vu  (pur-ee!vu   or better:   pur-ee!norris)