[net.games.frp] Review: Monster Manual II and D&D cartoon show

pugh@cornell.UUCP (William Pugh) (09/20/83)

in the stores, and refuse to buy it, so this will be a limited review.
The format is much the same as in the previous MM.  Charts for
randomly dicing monsters from all three books (MM, Fiend Folio, MM II)
are included in the back.  About a quarter of the monsters are just
very silly (e.g. Bowlders, creatures which look like rocks and bounce
down slopes to crush characters).  The official monsters from the past
several issues of the Dragon are included.  Some more non-human races/
species are included, but they only get the standard quarter of a page,
which is no where near enough to properly describe another race. 
   In addition, Gygax tells us that he expects to put out at least one or
two more editions of the Monster Manual. 
   Oppps, I almost forgot something: Monster Manual, Fiend Folio, Monster
Manual II, Dungeons and Dragons, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, and Gygax are
trademarks of TSR, and are used without permission.  There, thats taken care of.I woundn't want to get sued by one of TSR's many lawers. 
   I also saw the Dungeons and Dragons cartoon show on Saturday morning.  
The story concerns six kids who get sent to a fantasy world while
riding an amusment park ride.  They are given magic items and character
classes by a weird gnome like creature who calls himself the Dungeon Master
(side note: I'll bet official D&D never gets out of the dungeons and
into role-playing until they start using the term Game Master). The items
are somewhat interesting because Saturday morning censorship rules say
that you can not hit someone with a weapon, or show a sharp or pointed
weapons.  So the ranger's bow fires arrows that seem to be made out
of light and are conjured out of thin air.  All the barbarian has done
with his club so far is hit the ground and causes a bookcase to fall on
their opponent. In order to avoid anything which looks like real magic,
the magic-user character is limited to pulling things out of hat.
  Overall, it's an interesting effort, and perhaps preferable to watching
the Smurfs.                                           
   - Bill Pugh